Purpose-built Commercial Viability Assessments for PE and growth equity firms evaluating financial services technology investments.
Structured scoring. Sourced data. Consulting-grade deliverables. Built for deal timelines.
Learn How It WorksThe Commercial Conviction Gap is the disconnect between how PE firms create value and how they evaluate targets. Revenue growth now drives more than 60% of PE value creation (McKinsey Private Equity Practice, 2023), yet commercial execution remains the least rigorously assessed dimension of diligence.
Funds invest based on financial models and technical architecture reviews, then discover post-close that the commercial engine — go-to-market motion, competitive positioning, customer economics — cannot support the growth thesis. The problem is structural: most commercial diligence is either outsourced to generalist consultants who lack domain expertise or conducted informally by deal teams without a structured framework.
Financial services technology companies — with their complex buyer personas, regulatory environments, and competitive dynamics — require specialized commercial assessment.
of PE-backed companies cite commercial execution failure as their primary value gap.
Bain & Company, 2024
of PE leaders say go-to-market diligence is the biggest hole in their evaluation process.
Blue Ridge Partners, 2023
A Commercial Viability Assessment (CVA) is a structured, scored evaluation of a company's commercial readiness across eight weighted dimensions, designed specifically for PE and growth equity firms evaluating financial services technology investments. Gray Carroll's CVA framework produces a composite score on a 1–5 scale that quantifies commercial viability and surfaces both strengths and risks.
Unlike generalist commercial diligence, the CVA is calibrated specifically for finserv technology companies — WealthTech, Investment Management, Banking Technology, RegTech, Cybersecurity for FIs, and Alternative Investment platforms.
Weighted 1–5 score across 8 workstreams with color-coded risk thresholds
Every claim sourced from public data, customer intelligence, and digital signals
Prioritized risk matrix with severity ratings and mitigation recommendations
Structured interviews across power users, recent wins, churns, and competitive losses
The CVA methodology evaluates targets across eight weighted workstreams, each scored 1–5 against PE investment criteria. Each workstream addresses a specific dimension of commercial viability, and the weights reflect relative importance to fund returns based on research across PE value creation patterns.
TAM sizing, growth trajectory, competitive density, market timing
Defensibility analysis, switching costs, feature parity, technical barriers
Sales motion efficiency, channel mix, AI integration maturity, scalability
NRR, churn, CAC payback, LTV:CAC ratio, expansion revenue, concentration risk
G2/Gartner presence, review sentiment, digital footprint, brand authority
12-interview structured program across 4 cohorts with scored synthesis
Executive depth, GTM leadership, bench strength, culture signals
Pricing model assessment, expansion levers, competitive pricing position
The composite score is a weighted average across all eight workstreams. Scores are intentionally conservative — PE firms respect caution over optimism.
Gray Carroll offers three CVA engagement tiers, calibrated to deal timeline, diligence depth, and investment stage. Each tier produces a consulting-grade deliverable with structured scoring and sourced findings.
Early screening, deal pipeline triage, initial IC review
Active diligence, LOI stage, pre-IC decisions requiring customer validation
Final diligence, platform build-outs, growth equity with operating model thesis
Gray Carroll Consulting provides specialized commercial due diligence for PE firms evaluating financial services technology companies. The firm is led by Brian Carroll, who brings 20+ years of commercial leadership across finserv technology — including roles at Nasdaq and DefenseStorm — spanning WealthTech, Investment Management, Banking Technology, RegTech, and Cybersecurity for FIs.
Finserv-only focus means fluency in the buyer personas, competitive dynamics, and regulatory context PE targets operate in. No learning curve on sector fundamentals.
20 years building GTM functions inside the companies PE firms evaluate — product marketing, competitive intelligence, positioning, pricing — not observing from the outside.
AI-augmented research and analysis delivers Express-tier CVAs in 5–7 days without cutting analytical corners.
Deliverables built to McKinsey/Bain/BCG consulting standards: action titles, sourced data, SCQA narrative structure, conservative scoring.
A CVA is a structured, scored evaluation of a company's commercial readiness across eight weighted dimensions — from market positioning and competitive moat to customer economics and organizational depth. It produces a composite score on a 1–5 scale with risk-flagged findings and recommendations, designed specifically for PE and growth equity investment decisions.
A CVA Express engagement takes 5–7 business days from kickoff to deliverable. The Standard tier takes 2–3 weeks and includes Voice of Customer interviews. The Strategic Advisory tier extends to 3–4 weeks with a post-close acceleration plan.
The CVA methodology is calibrated specifically for financial services technology companies, including WealthTech, Investment Management platforms, Banking Technology, RegTech, Cybersecurity for FIs, TAMP platforms, Alternative Investment data platforms, and Fund Administration technology.
Traditional commercial diligence is typically generalist — the same consultant assessing a healthcare SaaS company also evaluates a finserv platform. The CVA is domain-native, built by someone with 20+ years inside finserv technology. It uses a structured scoring methodology with weighted workstreams rather than qualitative narrative, and delivers a quantified composite score that maps directly to PE investment criteria.
The deliverable is a consulting-grade PowerPoint deck following McKinsey/BCG/Bain presentation standards — action titles (not label titles), sourced data on every slide, SCQA narrative structure, color-coded scoring, risk assessment matrices, and recommended next steps. It's designed for direct use in investment committee presentations.
The VoC program is a structured interview series across four customer cohorts: power users, recent wins, churns, and competitive losses. The Standard tier includes 6 interviews across 2 cohorts; the Strategic Advisory tier includes 12 interviews across all 4 cohorts. Findings are scored and synthesized into the overall CVA.
Whether you're screening a pipeline target or deep in diligence, a CVA gives you the commercial clarity to invest with confidence.
Get in Touch